The unfortunate news came down Tuesday that Devils goalie Martin Brodeur will have surgery Thursday to repair a torn distal biceps tendon in his left elbow suffered during a Saturday win against Atlanta. The future Hall of Famer is not expected back until February at the earliest and his streak of playing in 70-plus games will come to an end at 10 straight seasons.
At least the Devils got better news than the New England Patriots (NFL) did when they lost star quarterback Tom Brady for the entire season due to a torn ACL suffered in the first quarter of a Week 1 game against the Kansas City Chiefs. Losing Brodeur in Fantasy Hockey rivals that of losing Brady in Fantasy Football. Both of them were high-end first-round picks and usually non-replaceable.
We sympathize with Brodeur owners since trying to find a player with equal value is going to be tough. But we remind you that Marc-Andre Fleury owners went through a similar situation last season when he spent many months on IR recovering from ankle injury. Fleury returned in late February and won 10 of his last 14 starts.
If you can afford to stash Brodeur, it is highly recommended. For those who need a stopgap option in the interim, we'll dedicate the rest of this space to help sift through what's left on waivers to get you over the hump.
Even Rick DiPietro owners might want to take a quick look at the remaining Fantasy scraps since the Islanders' top netminder and usual No. 2 Fantasy goalie is expected to miss 4-6 weeks following knee surgery.
Kevin Weekes, New Jersey
Owned: 43 percent of leagues
Analysis:
The heir apparent to Brodeur, the seldom-used backup has been the top
pickup in CBSSports.com leagues this week. Weekes is a former
second-round pick of the Panthers back in 1993. He has been a full-time
starter on four occasions in his first 11 seasons, so it's not like the
Devils are throwing a young pup into the fire. They added him last year
as added insurance and are plenty happy to have Weekes in net.
Fantasy
Take: Weekes is a must-add in all Fantasy formats since the Devils'
defense is one of the best. He should produce very well in Brodeur's
absence.
Kari Lehtonen, Atlanta
Owned: 57 percent of leagues
Analysis:
Lehtonen has not played since Oct. 30 because of an illness and now back
issues. Lehtonen has had his own injury problems since arriving
full-time in 2005-06, but don't forget this is a kid that won 34 games
in 2006-07. He landed a four-year extension in the offseason and is
coach John Anderson's goalie of choice when healthy. The only negative
going against Lehtonen is that the Thrashers are still a bottom feeder
in the Eastern Conference.
Fantasy Take: Lehtonen has
potential to be a very solid No. 2 Fantasy goalie and can be considered
a viable option since he is a starting NHL goalie.
Peter Budaj, Colorado
Owned: 61 percent of leagues
Analysis:
Budaj seems to be as hot-and-cold as they come in the NHL. He opened the
season with three straight losses before Andrew Raycroft started pushing him for playing time. Budaj then won
three straight games and looked well on his way to solidifying the No. 1
job in Colorado. He has since gone winless in his last three starts and
has a 5.55 GAA in two November outings.
Fantasy Take: Budaj
still remains a decent No. 2 Fantasy goalie since coach Tony Granato has
given him the benefit of the doubt. He will lose some starts to
Raycroft, but Budaj will have some nice runs and could post some
Brodeur-like Fantasy totals during those streaks.
Nikolai Khabibulin, Chicago
Owned: 62 percent of leagues
Analysis:
Chicago spent a ton of money in the offseason to sign Cristobal Huet, but when they couldn't unload Khabibulin, they were stuck
with two starting goalies. Even with coach Joel Quenneville taking over
as head coach, he still splits starts between Huet and Khabibulin. The
latter has been very strong in his first seven outings, going 4-1-1 with
a 2.38 GAA and .919 save percentage.
Fantasy Take: Chicago is
still willing to list offers for Khabibulin and don't be surprised if
New Jersey comes a calling if Weekes doesn't work out. Khabibulin still
remains a viable No. 3 Fantasy goalie, but it could be awhile until he
becomes a reliable option.
Dwayne Roloson, Edmonton
Owned: 24 percent of leagues
Analysis:
Speaking of trade bait, the Oilers are carrying three goalies -- Mathieu Garon, Jeff Drouin-Deslaurie
and Roloson. They can't send Drouin-Deslaurie back to the minors without
sending him through waivers and Edmonton can't really afford to keep
three goalies all season. Garon is usually the starter in Edmonton, but
Roloson has the hot hand and is seeing a few extra appearances. It could
also be to help expose Roloson as a potential trade candidate for those
teams looking for goalie help, like the Devils.
Fantasy Take: Roloson
still remains at best a No. 3 Fantasy goalie because of the goalie mess
in Edmonton, but could be worth stashing in larger leagues in the event
he is dealt away.
Alex Auld, Ottawa
Owned: 56 percent of leagues
Analysis:
Auld came into the season as the clear backup to Martin Gerber, but after Gerber struggled in the early season and then
dealt with a leg injury, Auld has started the last six games for Ottawa.
He has won three of those games and hasn't allowed more than three goals
in his last five contests.
Fantasy Take: The Senators have
shown in the past they have no problems with riding the hot hand. Gerber
is not totally out of the picture, but for right now Auld is their
starter. Be careful with Auld -- he could be a viable Fantasy option for
the time being but the rug could be pulled out from under him at any
moment.
Joey MacDonald, N.Y. Islanders
Owned: 21 percent of
leagues
Analysis: The Islanders weren't exactly sure what to
expect from MacDonald after losing reliable backup Wade Dubielewicz (signed overseas). Well, he has proven to be very
valuable since DiPietro has hardly played due to injury. MacDonald has
won four of his nine appearances and has a .903 save percentage. He has
won his last two starts and has made 66 saves in that span.
Fantasy
Take: MacDonald is a viable stopgap option while DiPietro is out,
but he will return to being a backup once DiPietro is healthy.
First-year coach Scott Gordon eyes DiPietro as a franchise goalie and
the Islanders are going to make sure they get some kind of return after
giving him a 15-year contract.
Jason LaBarbera, Los Angeles
Owned: 38 percent of leagues
Analysis:
LaBarbera opened the season as the Kings' starting goalie, but has gone
just 3-5-1 in 10 appearances with a 3.01 GAA and .884 save percentage.
His poor performance has opened the door for Erik Ersberg to possibly get a few more starts. The Kings, however,
aren't likely yet toying with the idea of bringing up prospect Jonathan Bernier since he is struggling down in the AHL (1-1-1, 3.58
GAA, .874 save percentage).
Fantasy Take: LaBarbera is still
not out of the picture in L.A., but the Kings aren't going to contend in
the Western Conference and the wins could be hard to come by. LaBarbera
is a desperation Fantasy replacement for Brodeur and DiPietro owners.
Best of the Rest
Pekka Rinne (owned 13 percent), Chris Mason (15 percent), Michael Leighton (12 percent), Tobias Stephan (7 percent)
Fantasy Take: All four of
these guys are pushing their respective competition, but it is still
going to take an injury or a strong leap of faith from the coaching
staff to become full-time starters. They remain primarily handcuff
Fantasy options.
You can e-mail us your Fantasy Hockey questions to DMFantasyPucks@cbs.com. Be sure to put Attn: Brodeur in the subject field. Please include your full name, hometown and state. Be aware, due to the large volume of submissions received, we cannot guarantee personal responses to all questions.