While some of college football might have questioned Alabama's spot at No. 5 in the first set of College Football Playoff rankings on Tuesday, no one is doubting the Crimson Tide's bona fides after a thunderous 31-13 win against No. 14 LSU in Baton Rouge on Saturday night.
In fact, college football fans may be asking bigger questions, like whether this Keelon Russell-led group should be among the top picks to win the national championship.
It's unlikely that Alabama, with two losses already this season, is going to seriously challenge for No. 1 in the rankings before other teams take losses. But in a 12-team College Football Playoff world, the key is to make the bracket by playing your best football, and while it took a while for Alabama to get rolling, the Crimson Tide seem to be getting healthy at the right time with a quarterback who can make plays against anyone.
Keelon Russell and the Alabama offense were mostly bottled up in the first half before cashing in on some explosive plays late in the game to pull away for the win. Russell finished with just 206 passing yards but three passing touchdowns, connecting with three different pass catchers for each score. Star wide receiver Ryan Coleman-Williams also made a multi-purpose splash in his return from injury, running in a touchdown and delivering a field-flipping punt return in the fourth quarter.
What was particularly frustrating for LSU was that it moved the ball effectively but failed to convert that success into points. The Tigers were stopped on fourth down four times, missed a field goal and ended the first half with a Sam Leavitt interception as LSU was driving into Alabama territory. LSU out-gained Alabama (366-to-286), but with an 18-point deficit on the scoreboard, it's hard to get too excited about winning in the box score.
Moving forward, Alabama is well-positioned to finish the season in the thick of the College Football Playoff race, with games against Vanderbilt, Chattanooga and Auburn left on the schedule. If Alabama was considered by the selection committee the No. 5 team before this win, then their stock is certainly only going up after winning by this margin on the road in Baton Rouge.
For LSU, the path to the playoff has just become much more complicated as the Tigers fall to 6-3 overall. The bad news is having three losses at this point in the schedule does not make finishing at 9-3 or better a likely proposition. The good news is there will be opportunities to prove that LSU is the best three-loss team in the country. Next week's home date against Texas is clearly a must-win, but so is the following week's trip to Knoxville for Lane Kiffin to face off against another former employer in Tennessee. If LSU wins out, it will have beaten multiple ranked teams and thus will have a decent argument for an at-large bid.
The issue is considering whether LSU has the team to win out against that schedule given some of the shortcomings on display against Alabama. If LSU cannot get better at cashing in on scoring opportunities, then all the pomp and circumstance about the Lane Kiffin hire and their multi-million-dollar portal class will only result in an 8-4 record and an early start on the next portal cycle.