"Madden NFL 25" is coming soon. And now we have a taste of the game's player ratings, with Miami Dolphins star Tyreek Hill revealed as the first member of this year's "99 Club."
Which players will join Hill as the top-rated wide receivers in "Madden 25"? And how about the safeties tasked with covering such explosive pass catchers? Below, we've got a full rundown of the top 10 overall-rated players at both positions in "Madden NFL 25," plus our reaction to the ratings:
Top 10 WRs
| Player | Team | Rating | Our Grade |
|---|---|---|---|
Tyreek Hill | Dolphins | 99 | Just Right |
98 | Too Low | ||
96 | Just Right | ||
95 | Just Right | ||
95 | Just Right | ||
94 | Just Right | ||
93 | Too Low | ||
92 | Just Right | ||
91 | Too High | ||
91 | Just Right |
Hill may not be a full tier above guys like Brown and Chase as the ratings suggest, but he deserves the "99" for his unmatched speed alone; no one can fly downfield like he does, even at 30. Jefferson has consistently been the NFL's top play-maker when healthy, so it's odd he doesn't share the "99" designation. Chase drawing a "93" feels like maybe the biggest slight, considering he's nearly matched Jefferson in big-play splash when fully healthy. Aiyuk, meanwhile, could arguably use another year of All-Pro production to be squarely affixed in the elite category.
Top 10 safeties
| Player | Team | Rating | Our Grade |
|---|---|---|---|
97 | Too High | ||
Buccaneers | 94 | Too Low | |
93 | Just Right | ||
Derwin James Jr. | 91 | Just Right | |
91 | Too High | ||
90 | Too High | ||
Kevin Byard III | 89 | Too High | |
89 | Too Low | ||
49ers | 88 | Just Right | |
Dolphins | 88 | Too High |
Contrary to wide receiver, which feels especially indebted to today's young and emerging stars, the safety group here plays like a who's who of yesteryear. Mathieu, Baker and Byard have all been top-shelf defenders at different points in their career, but injuries and inconsistencies have plagued them more recently; their names currently feel a bit bigger than their on-field results. It's astounding, actually, that Hamilton isn't clocking in ahead of them after a do-it-all breakout at the heart of the Ravens' elite defense. Winfield, meanwhile, has arguably been just as dominant patrolling the back end as Bates.
